Tuesday, August 21, 2007

The Inheritance of Loss by Kiran Desai

The Inheritance of Loss is more difficult than most books to sum up in a brief review. Set in the 1980s, at first, the main character seems to be Sai. She's an Indian teen who becomes an orphan when her parents, among the first astronauts in the Indian space program, are run over by a bus in Moscow. (That seems a little contrived to me.) Sai is forced to move in with her grandfather, a retired judge living in the Himalayan foothills near Darjeeling. The judge becomes a main character, as does his poor cook, and also the cook's son Biju, who's an illegal immigrant in New York. Minor characters are also studied in greater detail than in many books.

Sai's love interest is is Gyan, an ethnic Gorkha (Nepali) who becomes involved with the Gorkhaland National Liberation Front (which, I assume most non-Indian, non-Nepali readers will have never heard of).

The book could be described as beautiful, with lots of slices of the reality of life in the post-Colonial era. The experiences of Indians are looked upon (or at least Desai's views of them). For example, while there are exceptions, Biju is assumed to be the common-man Indian emigrant. Without a green card, he has a tough time of it in New York, leaving the reader to wonder whether or not America is all that it's cracked up to be. Where is ones home after all?

If the book has a flaw, in my opinion, it's the time spent with the GNLF. I suppose a novel needs to have some extra conflict introduced. But to me, the slices of life were so vivid and compelling that this wrinkle hardly seemed to be needed.

Despite winning the Man Booker prize, it seems to have more than the normal share of negative reviews over at Amazon.com. As of this writing, it's rated at three stars out of five. I'll do better than that and give it three and one half stars. However, Desai can do better.

1 comment:

dfv said...

I nearly started reading this a couple of weeks ago, so I tried not to read your review too carefully. Instead I read the latest Dave Eggers one, and now I'm onto something else. You really seem to have picked up the reading pace these days Dave.